The 2nd Marlo Cup Mapping Contest(Taiko) Result

Result

Exhibition Match

Champion

WINNER WINNER CHICKEN DINNER!

05

Song: EXOTICA

Author's Titular: Laosi Biniqiang 3rd Season

Score 95.34 Critiria 0

Rank 1/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsarLuiCat(Kuromaku)
90/10017/2085/10088/10017/20Rank 1

Comments(untranslated):

yutong

十分sota的谱面,虽然很想批判,但作者无懈可击

Note: Red fonted scores are for judges, calculated by choosing score on rank X from the judge itself, in which rank X is given by Kuromaku(LuiCat).

Second Place

04

Song: Cleopatrysm

Author's Titular: Firce777

Score 85.82 Critiria -1.5

Rank 2/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsarLuiCat(Kuromaku)
86/10017/2082/10081/10018/20Rank 4

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Though it seems a little overmapping, this map is undoubtedly great.

yutong

十分超车的谱面,用的有特色当然是亮点,但是散音段没有表现出相配的质量

Critiria Violates:

-1 (tja format) SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF not filled in

-0.5 note too close to previous renda at #29 etc.

Third Place

09

Song: ULTRA B+K

Author's Titular: you_s

Score 71.92 Critiria -1.5

Rank 3/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
91/10014/2074/10090/10015/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

It seems few detail problems, but the map is still not a great one. From donscore, I find this map is lacking in neatness, which make me unimpressed by it after playing.

yutong

十分BK的谱面,很带感,没什么可吐槽的

Critiria Violates:

-1 (tja format) SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF not filled in

-0.5 (tja format) gogotime missing

Admirable Charts

01

Song: Braid & Blade

Author's Titular: zzq0647

Score 51.39 Critiria 0

Rank 7/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
83/10014/2072/10081/10013/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Why don't you following melody exactly at some measures such as #08, #35-37? It's wasteful.

yutong

十分12分的谱面,并且使用了18分音。

02

Song: 閃鋼のブリューナク

Author's Titular: 水都

Score 2.74 Critiria -1

Rank 10/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
71/10011/2064/10063/10011/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Nonsense map. Especially, I can't understand your thinking on #54-61. It's that playing piano? Please remap it.

yutong

十分清奇的谱面,作者试图跟随副歌背景的16分旋律,但是效果很魔能,12+16的游玩感并不舒适。

Critiria Violates:

-1 (tja format) wrong SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF (SCOREINIT:SCOREDIFF = 470:80 = 5.875:1 > 5:1)

03

Song: CHERNOBOG

Author's Titular: AMAMI.A

Score 39.96 Critiria -1

Rank 8/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsarLuiCat(Kuromaku)
77/10015/2067/10076/10013/20Rank 7

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Not bad as a whole. but the rhythm is wrong on #9, #61, please fix it.

yutong

十分撞车的谱面,连id都叫2。24分发狂还是异色太难了,这种难度分配比燎原还要夸张

Critiria Violates:

-1 (tja format) SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF not filled in

06

Song: Flashback

Author's Titular: 爆炸蘑菇123

Score 51.69 Critiria -0.5

Rank 6/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
87/10016/2070/10071/10013/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Not bad. However, it's too bored to play this map. You can try to complicate #01-70.

yutong

十分发狂的谱面,曲子很清新我喜欢,但是太发狂了

Critiria Violates:

-0.5 (tja format) SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF not the best solution

07

Song: イシュカンコミュニケーション

Author's Titular: carbonara

Score 53.14 Critiria -0.5

Rank 5/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
81/10015/2076/10074/10014/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

This song seems interesting because of its special rhythm pattern, but there are few drumrolls or balloons for transition, which makes the map boring.

yutong

十分24分的谱面,并且使用了16分音。这样曲子的问题是似乎怎样写也不会违和,而我感觉作者基本都是随便写的

Critiria Violates:

-0.5 note too close to previous renda at #2 etc.

-0 inaccurate BPM, however zure through the whole chart is less than 20ms

08

Song: 星に願いを -Arrange ver.-

Author's Titular: snowsurvivor

Score 68.47 Critiria -0.5

Rank 4/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsarLuiCat(Kuromaku)
86/10016/2082/10076/10014/20Rank 2

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

The ""oox"" on #35 is a wet blanket. It seems to go against your mapping idea.

yutong

十分7星的谱面,但也许写个5星更好?我会给5星高分但也许其他评委不是这么想的

Critiria Violates:

-0.5 note too close to previous renda at #25 etc.

10

Song: 絶対零度

Author's Titular: Sand Suna (҉´҉・҉ω҉・҉`҉)

Score 10.85 Critiria -3

Rank 9/10

Original Scores:

Firce777Howard_YsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
76/10012/2062/10069/10010/20

Comments(untranslated):

Howard_Y

Is it 9 star? You're kidding me! Indescribable HS and rough details make this map worse, so I can't give your map high marks.

yutong

十分变速的谱面,但是并不需要这么多变速。一个谱面究竟是给自己玩的还是别人玩的呢?

Critiria Violates:

-1 (tja format) SCOREINIT and SCOREDIFF not filled in

-1 serious zure. OFFSET mismatches bgm sound wave.

-1 obvious jactitation in LEVEL

Quest Match

Winners to Exhibition Match

Quest Song #1 Champion

1B

Author: Sand

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 61.75

Rank 1/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
83/10080/10072/10080/10013/20

Quest Song #1 Second Place

1E

Author: SHEKDIAN

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 61.37

Rank 2/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
73/10085/10085/10080/10012/20

Quest Song #2 Champion

2A

Author: you_s

Song: Air Man ga Taosenai

Score 89.58

Rank 1/1

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
85/10080/10090/10085/10016/20

Admirable Charts

1A

Author: freetadey

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 38.41

Rank 5/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
74/10065/10064/10091/10014/20

1C

Author: Blake_Saligia

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 57.42

Rank 4/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
81/10075/10070/10090/10012/20

1D

Author: Zpmzpm

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 58.85

Rank 3/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
75/10075/10074/10095/10014/20

1F

Author: aki

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 29.31

Rank 6/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
76/10075/10066/10065/10011/20

1G

Author: nikkukun

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 19.40

Rank 7/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
71/10070/10067/10075/1009/20

1H

Author: ArsraizNork

Song: Frantic Wolf

Score 12.10

Rank 8/8

Original score:

Firce777laosibiniqiangsnowsurvivoryutongMyamsar
68/10070/10069/10070/1008/20

Quest Songs

Mapper Notice

After downloading quest songs and template charts, you can use In-game Editor or any other notepad tools for mapping one of the three quest songs.

When you completed your chart, you need to send chart file(.mc or .tja) to the organizers by any private way. (see Submission Requirements)

Please do not let others know your chart before the results are published.

Quest songs is publishing in Aug 7, 2017, and submissions is accepted from then.

We stops accepting submissions at GMT 10:00 AM, Aug 21.

Submission Methods

By Email

You can send your chart file(.mc or .tja)to the organizer's e-mail address([email protected]), note your Malody id in mail. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Check your mailbox frequently to receive feedbacks.

By Discord

Join Malody discord group: https://discord.gg/mMAhS9w and send your chart file privately to LuiCat. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Please keep contact with us.

By Tencent QQ

Add Friend to LuiCat at QQ 632977197 with annotation "Marlo Cup" and your Malody id. Then, send your chart file in way of Offline Files. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Please keep contact with us.

Submission Requirements

After downloading template charts, you can use In-game Editor or any other notepad tools for mapping. We only accept charts in .mc or .tja formats.

The level of accepted charts must be Lv.15-Lv.39, which is Mania(Oni) 5-stars to 10-stars based on standard from Taiko no Tatsujin (before AC15). Chart with over-ranged level would be rejected.

About .tja format: #SCROLL, #HBSCROLL, #MEASURE, #BARLINEOFF, and other unlisted commands for effects is banned from current match. Please be noticed that any uses of these commands will be removed with or without noticing.

Organizers

Man in Charge (Kuromaku)

Judgers

Competition Flow

Match 1: Quest Match

Quest Songs Published: Aug 7, 2017

Quest songs and template charts are published, download-able via Malody game.

Submission Time: Aug 8 - Aug 21 GMT10:00

Participants starts mapping and submit their charts.

Judging Time: Aug 21 - Aug 28

Judgers evaluates the submitted charts, and rankings are calculated.

Accepted charts are uploaded to the server, keeping participants anonymous by marking with numbers. Proxy statement is allowed if some participant wants to speak on behalf of its chart: Two oppotunities, up to 280 letters (bytes), send LuiCat the text and which place the statement to be published by original method of submission.

During this stage, stable charts of lower difficulties are published for play.

Result Published: Aug 29

Results(scores/ranking) of Quest Match are published. Member list who are admitted to Exhibition Match is also published.

Approved charts are set stable after match.

Match 2: Exhibition Match

Submission Time: After Quest Match - Sept 4 GMT4:00

Top mappers create charts freely for competation.

Judging Time: Sept 4 - Sept 19

Result Published: Around Sept 20

Submission Methods

By Email

You can send your chart file(.mc or .tja)to the organizer's e-mail address([email protected]), note your Malody id in mail. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Check your mailbox frequently to receive feedbacks.

By Discord

Join Malody discord group: https://discord.gg/mMAhS9w and send your chart file privately to LuiCat. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Please keep contact with us.

By Tencent QQ

Add Friend to LuiCat at QQ 632977197 with annotation "Marlo Cup" and your Malody id. Then, send your chart file in way of Offline Files. After reply, your chart is accepted to the contest. Please keep contact with us.

Submission Requirements

After downloading template charts, you can use In-game Editor or any other notepad tools for mapping. We only accept charts in .mc or .tja formats.

The level of accepted charts must be Lv.15-Lv.39, which is Mania(Oni) 5-stars to 10-stars in standard from Taiko no Tatsujin (before AC15). Chart with over-ranged level would be rejected.

About .tja format: #SCROLL, #HBSCROLL, #MEASURE, #BARLINEOFF, and other unlisted commands for effects is banned from current match. Please be noticed that any uses of these commands will be removed with or without noticing.

Scoring Rule

Each participant is given original scores in 0-100 from every judge. Then final score is calculated by algorithm: (1) Normalize scores of each judge, (2) Calculate the average score with half weight of the best and the least score cut down. (See descriptions below)

The Kuromaku also gives scores, for replacing scores of participated judges from themselves: If the judge get rank X from the Kuromaku, rank-X-score from the judge itself is used for a replacement.

The Final Score Algorithm

(1) Normalization

For some judge, the maximum score from the judge is Smax, and the minimum is Smin. Normalized score S' is calculated by original score S:

S'=100*(S-Smin)/(Smax-Smin)

(2) Top-Bottom-Half-Weighted Mean

For some chart, the normalized scores are sorted to a list Si, with i between [1,n]. The score to be cut down (by standards of chart format) is Mis. Final score Sum of the chart is calculated:

Sum=(ΣSi-(S1+Sn)*0.5)/(n-1)-Mis

Awards

Admittion to Exhibition Match (Quest Match Only)

From every quest song, at least one or at least twenty percent of participants is admitted to Exhibition Match.

Prize (Quest Match Only)

Top mappers from every quest song is awarded with amount of prize money determined by numbers of participants of the quest.

Stabled Charts

Qualified charts are set stable, lower difficulties being completed by organizers.

In-Game Golds

Gold for every participants!

Conclusion

The purpose of the competition is "exchange first, competition second", so we hope the participants, the audience and the members of the organizing committee be active and harmonious in discussions in compliance with the match rules, and try to avoid conflict with others.

Competition organizers (the Organizing Committee) has the final interpretation of match rules and all arrangements. Any comments or suggestions on the contest may be conveyed in any public communication ways, where members of committee are able to learn and reply, and we appreciate your discussion.

Sign inX

Sign in

Forgot Password? Register

Wait...