The result of The 4th Marlo Cup Mapping Contest(Key) has come out!
Tip : As these comments are written in chinese originally, so we just translate the comment for charters who can't read chinese.
Contest staff
Organizer
Course Selector
Judge
Ranking
Champion
Creator : yoshilove
Award : $ 20 + 5000 Gold + Custom Banner for 2 month + "Gold Chart" Award
评委评语 :
You must be famliliar with this song right? :3
nice。(it's like 7k more)
第二名
Creator : laosibiniqiang
Award : 5000 Gold + Custom Banner for 2 month
第三名
Creator : luyzi
Award : 5000 Gold + Custom Banner for 2 month
优秀的参赛者
4th
Chart : Jyuunouseigou-3C
Creator : Demigod
Score : 23.5(7.5+7.5+4.5+4.0)
Award : 5000 Gold
5th
Chart : Jyuunouseigou-3D
Creator : WANDER
Score : 23.0(8.0+7.0+5.0+3.0)
Award : 5000 Gold
评委评语 :
If you rearrange some strange patterns, it'll be better.
Try thinking over the pattern again.
6th
Chart : Elina-1E
Creator : TheNewBungping
Score : 22.5(7.5+6.5+5.5+3.0)
Award : 5000 Gold
评委评语 :
Your idea is suitable to this song, but you need to rearrange some patterns.
The patterns later on in the chart and the layering is a little messy.
Overall, it's probably an OK chart. there's still some small snap errors in places.
7th
Chart : Elina-1B
Creator : Potassium
Score : 22.0(9.0+7.0+4.0+2.0)
Award : 2000 Gold
8th
Chart : Elina-1D
Creator : SUPERSV
Score : 21.0(7.5+6.0+5.0+2.5)
Award : 2000 Gold
评委评语 :
The idea is not bad but it's too simple since Elina is a rich song.
Using less notes portrayed the rigid feel of the song. However, it made the chart feel frantic. Also, small errors with putting notes where there's a sound are present in the chart.
First I need to say that Easy ≠ High scores. However, I still have to compliment you seeing as there appears to be some consideration about how to place the drums. However, you can't cover these sounds just because you don't feel like catching them which is a truth. Also, the snapping of notes have obvious errors. Comparing some of the patterns in the chart with this, the gaps are pretty frightening.
English
9th
Chart : polylattice-2A
Creator : Maccaro_N
Score : 20.5(7.0+6.5+4.0+3.0)
Award : 5000 Gold
评委评语 :
Great map. Some issues exist. Some pattern is not so comfortable as it could be.
Sound catching is very clean. There are some parts that could lose your way easily, but considerint the song's properties.... (lol) Some places also have mistakes.
10th
Chart : Elina-1F
Creator : Xing_Ren
Score : 20.0(6.0+6.0+4.0+4.0)
Award : 2000 Gold
And..
Chart : Jyuunouseigou-3A
Creator : 1172557139
Score : 20.0(7.0+6.5+3.5+3.0)
Award : 2000 Gold
12th
Chart : Jyuunouseigou-3B
Creator : ArtyTeacher
Score : 19.5(6.0+6.0+5.0+2.5)
Award : 2000 Gold
评委评语 :
The middle part is comfortable to play! However your chart is lack of consistency.
Layering isn't very clear, the organisation of instruments isn't clear.
And..
Chart : Jyuunouseigou-3E
Creator : Ziel
Score : 19.5(6.5+6.0+4.5+2.5)
Award : 2000 Gold
14th
Chart : Elina-1C
Creator : Q-sher
Score : 17.0(7.5+5.0+3.0+1.5)
Award : 2000 Gold
15th
Chart : polylattice-2B
Creator : simongai
Score : *13.0**(6.0+4.0+2.0+1.0)
Award : 2000 Gold
16th
Chart : Elina-1A
Creator : 8230
Score : 9.5(4.0+4.0+1.0+0.5)
Award : 2000 Gold
Judge's Stable Recommendation
Ranking | ChartNumber | _Curta1n | Biemote | victorica | PHiZER |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st | 1G | √ | √ | √ | |
2nd | 3F | √ | √ | ||
3rd | 1H | √ | √ | ||
4th | 3C | √ | √ | √ | |
5th | 3D | √ | √ | ||
6th | 1E | √ | √ | ||
7th | 1B | √ | |||
8th | 1D | √ | |||
9th | 2A | √ | √ | ||
10th | 1F | √ | |||
11th | 3A | ||||
12th | 3B | ||||
13th | 3E | ||||
14th | 1C | √ | |||
15th | 2B | ||||
16th | 1A |
Chart with at least 2 "√" sign will remain stabled.
At the end...
In this Contest.we used a special anonymous scoring way.The judges don't know the charter when they are giving out the score.
After this event.These mentioned chart in Judge's stable Recommendation will get stable.Other charts will be back to beta.And now everyone can upload new chart on course song pages.
OK.See you next event~